Why Are Managers Not Leaders?

Are managers truly leaders?

In this article, I will discuss the key differences between the two positions of management and leadership.

By the end of this article, you will have a better understanding of management versus leadership and the necessary skills that a great leader should possess.

Let’s begin.

What Managers Do

As a manager, you have a number of responsibilities on your shoulders.

You have to manage teams that are responsible for specific tasks and ensure that these tasks are completed on time and to a high standard. You are in charge of allocating resources and monitoring progress to ensure that things are going according to plan. You are responsible for ensuring that budgets are met and that projects remain profitable.

You control your team by providing direction, making decisions, and providing feedback. You create a structure of roles and responsibilities that ensures everyone knows what they are doing and what is expected of them. You provide guidelines and rules for how work is conducted and what processes need to be followed. You monitor work to ensure that tasks are being completed on time and to a high standard.

While some level of control is necessary, it is important to recognize its limitations. Too much control can stifle creativity and limit innovation. It can reduce employee engagement and have a negative effect on employee retention. It can also create a culture of micromanagement and demotivate employees.

As a manager, you need to find the right balance between control and autonomy, so that your team is able to work together effectively, while also having the freedom to innovate and take risks.

How Leaders Influence Their Teams

As opposed to managers, who control their teams through established policies and guidelines, leaders influence their teams by guiding and inspiring them toward a common goal. By clearly communicating the vision of the organization, leaders ensure that their teams are aligned and motivated toward achieving success.

Leaders typically provide a clear roadmap for their team to follow, while also allowing room for experimentation and creativity. They actively collaborate with their team members to identify areas of improvement, while also providing the necessary resources and support to ensure their growth and development.

The importance of leadership in the success of an organization cannot be overstated. A strong leader is capable of fostering a culture of innovation and creativity that encourages team members to think outside the box and come up with new and better ideas.

To be an effective leader, it is important to develop excellent communication skills. The ability to communicate clearly and persuasively can help a leader inspire confidence in their team members and instill a sense of purpose and focus.

In order to maintain their influence, leaders must constantly lead by example. By consistently exhibiting the attributes and skills that they promote in their team members, leaders can earn the respect and admiration of their colleagues, and this can further enhance the influence they have on their team.

Overall, a leader’s role is to facilitate the success of their team by inspiring and guiding them towards excellence. They help unlock the full potential of their team members, making them feel valued, heard, and supported.

If you are aspiring to be a leader, focus on consistently communicating your vision, collaborating with your team members, and cultivating a culture of innovation and growth.

Short-Term Success vs Long-Term Success

As a manager, it is vital to focus on short-term success. This means that the objectives and goals that you set need to be achievable for the company within the next few months.

The targets that you set will ensure that the company is moving forward and doing its best to achieve its goals. Managers need to keep costs under control while increasing sales, thus ensuring that their quarterly and yearly targets have been met.

On the other hand, a leader’s role is to focus on the long-term success of the company. This means developing strategies that will keep the business successful in the long run.

Leaders need to be visionaries, creating a plan that will keep the company focused on success in the future. This approach can lead to significant growth and innovation within the company.

In addition to this, leaders need to focus on nurturing a culture of growth and innovation.

By doing so, they can provide the right environment that will encourage employees to come up with new ideas, engage with new technology, and showcase their creativity. As a result, leaders will be able to support and guide the team to long-lasting success by creating a more innovative and creative work environment.

It is easy to understand why managers focus on short-term success as it is essential for the company to meet its immediate targets, whereas leaders are responsible for the long-term success of the company, and hence their focus is on creating a vision and long-term goals.

As a manager or entrepreneur, it is important to create a tandem between the focus on short-term objectives and the long-term success of the company. You need to ensure that you are not only meeting the company’s immediate goals but also that you are working towards its long-term success.

By maintaining this balance, you will be able to create a company that can sustain growth and innovation, while still meeting the expectations of its stakeholders in the short term.

The Short-Sightedness of Managers

As the primary drivers of a company’s day-to-day operations, managers are tasked with maintaining order within the ranks, ensuring tasks are completed on time, and targets are achieved.

Their laser focus on short-term success, i.e., getting the job done quickly and efficiently, has earned them a reputation for being practical and efficient. However, their method of achieving success disregards what may be best for not only the present moment but also the future - something that effective leaders know all too well!

If you are a manager, your success is judged based on clear and measurable targets set by the company. Achieving these targets is necessary, for it drives short-term success, however, it can ultimately lead to narrow-minded policies as the focus remains on numbers and finances. For example, achieving targets for the present quarter by slashing employee salaries may offer a temporary solution for cost-saving, but it could prove catastrophic for the long-term growth of the company.

Managers are too often guided by several constraints, such as meeting short-term goals and keeping expenses limited, which can make it difficult to look beyond these elements.  This mindset can limit the creativity and innovation of the team, especially if management views creativity as a luxury or a distraction.

To be a great leader, try to avoid micromanaging every aspect of the job. When setting goals, prioritize long-term results, build a supportive company culture, and pay close attention to employee feedback. Strive to make your employees feel empowered and go the extra mile to support them if necessary.

By doing so, you create an environment that fosters creativity and encourages innovative ideas, both of which are essential for long-term success.

Leaders Focus on Long-Term Success

As I mentioned in the previous section, leaders focus on creating a vision and implementing long-term goals for the company. This means that leaders think beyond the quarterly and yearly objectives that managers work towards. Leaders invest the time and energy to develop strategies that will keep the business successful for many years to come.

One aspect that leaders pay attention to is the culture of the company. Leaders nurture a culture of growth and innovation where individuals are encouraged to share their ideas and take risks. This type of culture helps to promote creativity and assists in keeping the company competitive.

Another key aspect leaders consider is how the company will remain successful in the market for many years. This involves understanding future trends and developing strategies that take advantage of these trends. For example, if the rise of automation is projected for a particular market, a leader may invest in automation technologies and retrain the workforce to ensure they possess the necessary skills.

Overall, investing in long-term success ensures that the company stays ahead of the competition and is better equipped to handle any disruptions in the industry. Companies that have a clear vision and strategies for long-term success see higher growth and profitability in the future.

If you want your company to remain competitive in the long run, it’s important to focus on not just the present but also the future and develop the necessary strategies to ensure long-term success.

The Limits of Management

As a manager, I understand the complex and competing demands that come with the role. Pressure from upper management weighs heavy, and the need to follow guidelines and rules can make innovation feel stifled. At the same time, we are tasked with keeping costs under control, which often means making hard decisions that might not always be popular.

All these constraints can make it feel like we’re not doing enough, like we’re not being creative or making enough strides to lead our teams to success. But I believe that these are real and necessary constraints that managers must learn to operate within, and even use as a tool to encourage the team’s creativity.

No matter our opinions or gut instincts, we need to stay within certain bounds and there’s no such thing as free rein in a company. It can limit the amount of innovation possible, set roadblocks to problem-solving, and limit the ability to be agile and dynamic. However, constraints can also help us define our focus and enable us to look for certain kinds of solutions.

It’s important to understand that managers aren’t necessarily tasked with being creative. Instead, we’re responsible for making sure that people around us are effectively executing the tasks at hand. That’s where the boundaries come in. Wanting to achieve the established tactical objectives could be carried out through high efficiency and a well-structured process, and not necessarily by promoting creativity on individual tasks.

However, when aligned with the right methods, measuring the creativity of the team, and making sure everyone has opportunities to express and provide new ideas, can push out the boundaries and lead to huge innovations. Putting into place systems that measure creativity, could be a perfect way of doing this. Instead of getting the team focused solely on executing the immediate objective, have a long-term perspective and consider how we can harness their creativity to drive our business forward.

In the end, it’s the ability to work constructively within these constraints that sets great managers apart from average ones. Though the confines can feel limiting, it’s our job to navigate them with intelligence and grace.

The Role of Leadership

If you do not offer opportunities for your employees to grow, you risk losing them to companies that will. As a leader, it is your responsibility to nurture your employees and provide them with opportunities to advance. This can be achieved through training programs, mentorships, stretch assignments, and cross-functional roles.

Encouraging creativity in the workplace is also crucial. If you do not foster an environment that encourages creative thinking, you risk losing out on innovative ideas that could drive your company forward. You can encourage creativity by hosting brainstorming sessions, implementing open-door policies, and creating a culture that rewards risk-taking and experimentation.

Supporting the well-being of your team is also important. By prioritizing your team’s mental and physical health, you create a more productive and engaged workforce. This can be achieved by offering wellness programs, flexible work arrangements, and regular check-ins with employees.

When you prioritize growth, creativity, and well-being, you foster a more engaged, productive, and innovative workforce. As a leader, it is essential to offer these opportunities to your team.

The Importance of Both Managers and Leaders

If you have a company that either has only a manager or a leader, then that is not good for the long-term success of the company. Both managers and leaders play an essential role in the company’s success, and companies that have both can better achieve their long-term goals.

Managers are important because they help maintain a level of control over the company’s activities. This control is necessary to ensure that the company operates effectively to achieve its short-term goals. On the other hand, leaders bring fresh perspectives and innovative ideas to the table that lead to long-term growth and development.

It would help if you had both a capable manager and a seasoned leader in your company. When managers and leaders partner, it offers you the best of both worlds: managing the day-to-day operations while still providing long-term direction and growth. This combination optimizes the growth and success of the company.

Some successful companies that have found the importance of having the right balance of leaders and managers include Apple, Facebook, Amazon, and Google. Apple is a great example because Steve Jobs played the role of a great manager and leader; he was known for having a strong culture, a vision to make technology more approachable, and a strategy for future development.

In conclusion, transforming good companies into great ones needs capable managers and seasoned leaders. Companies that strike a proper balance can achieve a long-term sustainable competitive advantage, improve the bottom line, and win the hearts and minds of employees, shareholders and customers, driving growth and success overall.

Final Thoughts

In today’s post, I’ve explained the differences between managers and leaders, why both are important for success in any enterprise and how they complement each other.

As a leader with 20 years of experience, I’ve come to realize that creating a successful enterprise depends on cultivating management skills and leadership skills in equal measure.

I hope this post has given you new insights and has helped you to recognize the strengths of both management and leadership.

So, which leadership or management strategy are you going to try first?

I would love to hear from you! Please send me a message and let me know which idea resonated most with you.

If you found this blog post valuable, I would be grateful if you could share it on your social media networks.

Your sharing will help other managers and leaders learn the importance of balancing management and leadership in their businesses.

Are You a Visionary Leader? Find out with our self-assessment!

About the Author
Hi there, I'm James, founder of Melbado. I have over 20 years of experience as a leader and entrepreneur. Recently, I turned to leadership coaching and writing to pass on my knowledge to the next generation. If you have any questions or comments, please contact me via our contact page.


All the information on this website - https://melbado.com/ - is published in good faith and for general information purpose only. Melbado does not make any warranties about the completeness, reliability and accuracy of this information. Any action you take upon the information you find on this website (Melbado), is strictly at your own risk. Melbado will not be liable for any losses and/or damages in connection with the use of our website.

From our website, you can visit other websites by following hyperlinks to such external sites. While we strive to provide only quality links to useful and ethical websites, we have no control over the content and nature of these sites. These links to other websites do not imply a recommendation for all the content found on these sites. Site owners and content may change without notice and may occur before we have the opportunity to remove a link which may have gone 'bad'.

Please be also aware that when you leave our website, other sites may have different privacy policies and terms which are beyond our control. Please be sure to check the Privacy Policies of these sites as well as their "Terms of Service" before engaging in any business or uploading any information.

By using our website, you hereby consent to our disclaimer and agree to its terms.

Some of the links on this page may be affiliate links. If you purchase a product or service through an affiliate link, your cost will be the same, but we will automatically receive a small commission. Your support is greatly appreciated and helps us keep going!
Copyright © 2023 Melbado